“I didn’t like his driving style. He was speeding, but it took us way too long to get there. I didn’t feel safe and he wouldn’t stop bitching about the traffic. The rest of the weekend was pretty fun though. I just don’t know if we’d work out.”
A friend shared this with me after getting home from a weekend trip with a guy she’s potentially interested in. She asked me how I felt about bad drivers.
“I like to feel safe while a guy is driving, but he should also have a sense of urgency and not be afraid to run a few yellow lights.” Wait, since when did I have such a strong preference in the driving skills of a romantic partner?
We easily recounted the guys we’d dated and the quirks of each of their driving habits. “Billy drove like a grandma,” “Brad was always zoning out and not really paying attention,” “Ben acted like he was driving a Ferrari, even though it was a Honda Civic.” My friend firmly concluded bad drivers aren’t for her (along with men who don’t like spicy food). This got me thinking.
How much is someone’s “driving style” an indicator of their personality/compatibility? And can we really use a simple formula like bad driver=bad boyfriend to predict the quality/duration of a relationship?
“The Illusion of Patterns” is a useful idea to consider in this situation. In “Thinking, Fast and Slow,” Nobel Prize winner Daniel Kahneman explains how the human mind is wired to see patterns, even where none actually exist. Kahneman concludes:
“Statistics produce many observations that appear to beg for causal explanations but do not lend themselves to such explanations. Many facts of the world are due to chance, including accidents of sampling. Causal explanations of chance events are inevitably wrong.”
So what does this mean for us? Our “statistics” consist of previous boyfriends and their driving habits, and the small # of past relationships= an “accident of sampling”. Are we seeing a pattern between the quality of guy and their driving skills that doesn’t actually exist? Does this mean we should abandon our bad drivers=bad boyfriends theory?
No, we will not, but we will be a bit more lenient in our judgement, and we will recognize driving style doesn’t always dictate the quality of a partner. This should apply to both men and women. Just because a girl is a crazy driver (me) doesn’t mean she’s a crazy girlfriend.
Don’t worry, I’ll be posting an awesome graph my friend created comparing people to their driving skills!